State lawsuit alleges insurer used undisclosed claims-handling practices to systematically deny or underpay wind and hail damage claims.
Updated Wednesday morning to include Allstate’s response to the lawsuit.
OKLAHOMA CITY — Attorney General Gentner Drummond has filed a lawsuit accusing Allstate Insurance Co. of operating a coordinated scheme to systematically deny or underpay legitimate wind and hail damage claims submitted by Oklahoma homeowners, including allegations that the company violated Oklahoma’s Racketeer-Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act.
Filed Tuesday in Cleveland County District Court, the petition alleges Allstate implemented what it calls a “Disaster Payment Minimization Scheme” designed to reduce claim payments while increasing corporate profits. According to the lawsuit, the company marketed homeowners policies as providing replacement-cost coverage for storm-related damage while relying on undisclosed internal standards and claims-handling practices to limit coverage and reduce payments to policyholders.
Beyond alleging deceptive claims practices, the lawsuit contends Allstate and a network of captive agents, engineering firms, consulting firms and other entities operated what it describes as a “Denial Enterprise” that engaged in a pattern of racketeering activity to maximize profits by denying or underpaying valid property damage claims.
The petition alleges Allstate systematically stripped field adjusters of authority to approve claims, substituted third-party inspectors and reviewers in the claims process, adopted undisclosed internal definitions that were more restrictive than policy language, and relied on engineering reports and internal standards to reduce or deny payments for covered losses.
The lawsuit further alleges the company continued marketing policies as providing replacement-cost coverage while internally applying standards that resulted in homeowners receiving less than the cost to replace damaged property. It also alleges policyholders were not informed of those internal claims-handling standards or limitations when purchasing or renewing coverage.
“This lawsuit is about protecting Oklahoma homeowners and holding insurance companies accountable when they fail to honor the promises they make to policyholders,” Drummond said in a statement announcing the lawsuit. “Consumers pay their premiums expecting their insurance company to be there when disaster strikes. When insurers put profits ahead of policyholders, it’s hardworking families and individuals who ultimately pay the price.”
The state alleges the company’s conduct violated the Oklahoma Consumer Protection Act and the Oklahoma Racketeer-Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act. The petition also asserts claims of civil conspiracy and unjust enrichment. According to the lawsuit, the alleged pattern of racketeering activity includes repeated deceptive practices involving the sale and administration of homeowners insurance policies and the use of computer systems to carry out the alleged scheme.
Rather than seeking relief for individual policyholders, the attorney general argues the lawsuit is a public enforcement action aimed at dismantling what it describes as a company-wide system of deceptive practices affecting Oklahoma’s homeowners insurance market. The state contends the alleged conduct has harmed consumers, the broader economy and the integrity of the state’s insurance marketplace.
The lawsuit seeks a court declaration that Allstate violated Oklahoma consumer protection and anti-racketeering laws, a permanent injunction prohibiting the alleged practices, orders to dismantle the alleged racketeering enterprise, civil penalties, restitution for affected consumers and disgorgement of profits the state alleges were improperly retained.
Allstate rejected the allegations in a statement issued after the lawsuit was filed.
“This lawsuit has no merit and serves billboard lawyers who turn routine insurance claims into lawsuits, making insurance more expensive for everyone,” the company said. “Allstate is committed to supporting customers with timely and fair claim payments based on their policy to help them recover from storms.”
The filing is the latest lawsuit brought by the attorney general’s office against a property and casualty insurer over the handling of Oklahoma homeowners’ wind and hail claims.
Read the lawsuit.
