Opens in a new tab
Get the news straight to your inbox. Subscribe today to the OK Politics Today newsletter.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Go vote today in Oklahoma. See key elections at this link: https://okvoterportal.okelections.gov/
Court homeowners ruling
A home and vehicle sit damaged after an EF5 tornado struck Moore on May 20, 2013. Photo by Tim Allen.
October 5, 2026

Ruling clears way for hearing on Oklahoma homeowners insurance competition

The Oct. 2 order settles who will preside but leaves unanswered whether the market is competitive and what rate-review rules should apply.

OKLAHOMA CITY — Oklahoma homeowners are not getting an answer yet on whether their insurance market is competitive. But the state proceeding intended to answer that question can move again.

An Oct. 2 order rejected an effort by Attorney General Gentner Drummond and Republican insurance commissioner nominee Bob Sullivan to remove independent hearing examiner John D. Miller.

The order declared their separate request involving Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready moot because he has no role in deciding the case.

The ruling keeps Miller in place and directs the proceeding to resume “without further delay.”

It does not decide whether Oklahoma’s homeowners insurance market is competitive or approve or reject any insurance rate. It clears a procedural dispute that had stopped the hearing.

Why the hearing matters

Oklahoma homeowners have faced sharp premium increases and increasingly expensive coverage.

A Government Accountability Office report released this year found that homeowners insurance premiums consumed a larger share of median household income in Oklahoma, Florida and Louisiana than in any other states examined.

Oklahoma law currently presumes that its homeowners insurance market is competitive. That classification allows insurers greater freedom to put rates into effect and limits the department’s ability to reject them as excessive.

A finding that the market is not competitive would subject homeowners rates to the state’s more restrictive noncompetitive-market rules, including advance filing and review.

The distinction will narrow when House Bill 3781 takes effect July 1, 2027. The new law will require insurers to submit rates before using them and will allow the department to reject excessive rates even if the market remains classified as competitive.

After the law takes effect, rates in a competitive market will be subject to a 30-day waiting period. A noncompetitive finding would extend that review period to 60 days.

The hearing therefore could have a larger regulatory effect before July 2027. Afterward, it still would determine how long the department has to review proposed rates and whether Oklahoma’s legal presumption of competition matches the market consumers experience.

Why the proceeding stopped

Drummond and Sullivan argued that the structure and handling of the case created doubts about whether they would receive a fair hearing.

They sought Miller’s disqualification and asked Mulready to withdraw from any role in the decision.

A separate independent examiner, Stephan S. Mathis, found no evidence that Miller had improperly discussed the case with Insurance Department employees. He also found that Miller’s contract with the department did not give him a financial stake in the outcome.

“An aggregation of individually lawful and unremarkable circumstances does not become an appearance of partiality merely by being listed together,” Mathis wrote.

Mathis did not decide whether Mulready appeared biased. He ruled that the issue was moot because Mulready had delegated the case to Miller.

Under the order, Mulready will not preside over the hearing, decide whether the market is competitive or review Miller’s final decision.

What happens next

No new hearing date has been set.

Miller stayed the proceeding in September and struck all scheduled dates, including an Oct. 26 hearing. The Oct. 2 order allows the case to resume but does not restore that date.

Miller also must decide whether Sullivan and Democratic insurance commissioner nominee Craig MacIntyre may continue participating. The Insurance Department has argued that neither candidate has the direct personal or financial interest required to remain a party.

Sullivan and MacIntyre are running in the Nov. 3 election to succeed the term-limited Mulready.

Oklahoma law ordinarily provides judicial review after the Insurance Department issues a final order. The Oct. 2 ruling does not end the proceeding.

OK Politics Today asked Sullivan and Drummond’s office Monday whether they are considering a court challenge and whether they would seek immediate review or wait for a final agency order. This story will be updated with their responses.

The Insurance Department’s official record of the proceeding contains no new hearing date or court challenge.

With the election less than a month away, voters could choose the next insurance commissioner before the department determines whether the homeowners market that person will inherit is competitive.

Share this article:

About the Author